Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Orlando Memory: opinions and suggestions

On the OCLS Learn 2.1 program dated 2 December 2008, we were asked to visit Orlando Memory and Orange Seed. Here are my thoughts.

I like the concept of Orlando Memory as a place for people to share photographs and musings inspired by the City Beautiful. However, I'm sorry to say I don't find the website to be very intuitive to use. As someone who uses websites such as Flickr, I found the image uploading page to be rather confusing and foreign. The upload box is placed below a very large text window that gives users format and font options and other things which aren't really necessary for putting up a blurb about a trip to Epcot or talking about someone's A&W Root Beer stand.

Also frustrating is when a photo is uploaded, or when a new topic is started, there is a moderation time. I strongly feel pictures and topics hostage like this until someone somewhere takes a look at them is unnecessary. Giving users the opportunity to flag topics and photos as inappropriate should be sufficient, along with disabling or banning users who try to put up inappropriate photographs, as well as moderators who will click periodically through new pictures. For someone wanting to start a new topic, like "Orlando protest pictures," he or she must wait until the topic is approved before being allowed to upload photos. It's been 45 minutes since I submitted a topic for approval, and as of this moment, it is still in "pending" status. This isn't very user-friendly at all.

Furthermore, if a user wants to upload many pictures at once, there isn't a way to do that. Websites such as Flickr and Facebook have ways of uploading many photos at one time. Even uploading five photos at once would be a significant improvement to the current system.

I realise this post might be harsh, and I'm not meaning for it to be mean, but as someone who uses websites which utilise photographs and uploading, trying to use the Orlando Memory site is like trying to use a Commodore 64.

In complete seriousness, I want to post photos to Orlando Memory. Collecting photographs from Orlando's past and present will be a great way for us to see what has changed and where this city is going. This is why the Orlando Memory site needs a redesign. It doesn't have to be as swank as, say, Serious Eats--another type of community which utilises a forum and photo uploads--but at least be functional.

Again, my commentary isn't meant to be any sort of jab at the people who made Orlando Memory. It isn't meant to be personal, so please don't take it that way. As someone with nearly 500 photographs tagged "Orlando" in my Flickr account, I would love to contribute to this project. But the idea of waiting for ten, twenty, thirty photos to be approved is ridiculous.

Please redo Orlando Memory. I'll be happy to provide further suggestions or examples of good design to possibly incorporate, if welcome.

Friday, December 26, 2008

The subjective nature of cognitive surplus

In the Adventure Activity for the November 18th lesson, Web 2.0 Continues, the activity directed us to Clay Shirky's speech at the Web 2.0 conference. Shirky made some interesting points, but I don't think I completely agree with his views.

Firstly, Shirky needed to better articulate the differences between watching television and watching YouTube? For many, either way, you're sitting on your butt. Perhaps there is a bit of subversiveness with watching YouTube in that you're not necessarily watching something corporate giants are trying to shove down your throat (...or are you?). Maybe you burn more calories clicking and moving a mouse than a remote. Still, many people go online to watch television programs, whether it's the episode of Pushing Daisies you missed last Wednesday, or an obscure episode of Japanese anime cartoon Ge Ge Ge no Kitaro. Maybe they won't have to watch a commercial for a Sham-WOW, but advertising on the internet is out there, especially those that are tied-in to television commercials.

Second, I would like to point out Shirky's comparison of television-watching with Wikipedia contribution. I understand his point with regards to the TV producer's comment; however, his slant seems to suggest, "Oh, people watching television could be doing so much more with their free time, like contribute to Wikipedia!" Question: how many avid sitcom fans would actually contribute to Wikipedia if they weren't watching television?

So, I've contributed to Wikipedia. And I watch television. Not a lot, but I haven't really watched much in the past five years. Although it's easy to point at television to be this great and terrible SOMA, one can point to the internet as well. There have been many times I have gone online and felt like I wasted quite a bit of time on it. Even Wikipedia, that wonderful source of imperfect knowledge, can suck you in, as it did me when I followed link after link, reading various articles about numerous cheeses. Seriously, I think I spent at least half an hour, likely more, reading about different kinds of cheese. True, I learnt quite a bit about Emmenthaler cheese, but a television show on the Food Network could have informed me sufficiently (although I would have to wait for it to come on... unless I have a magic device called TiVo).

But what would have really informed me about cheese? Going to a cheese shop and asking someone working there about what they sell.

In 2007, I got my Bachelor's degree, and was done with school for the moment (I'm looking to go back next fall). Since then, I deleted my MySpace account, fell in and out of love with Last.fm, deepened my Etsy addiction and got cable television with my roommate. What do I love to do in my idle time? Sure, I go online on my breaks at work, but when at home, I play video games periodically, blog incredibly infrequently, read more often, and bake. For baking edification, I go online for recipes, but I also peruse my obscene collection of cookbooks.

I'm actually on the internet a lot less now that I'm out of school, which makes sense in one way, as I don't have as much research to do now, but I'm also spending less time on social networking websites. In fact, in the past year, I have actually watched more television, but that's because television is available. I watch television maybe an hour or two a day, and I'm picky with what I watch. If nothing appeals to me, I shut the TV off and read instead.

With regards to cognitive surplus and deciding what is worthwhile to spend one's time on, I belive it's entirely subjective. Working on Wikipedia articles can be seen as a contribution to society on one hand, but what if that person should really be working on, say, homework instead? Or, in my case, I'm reading a very interesting book about post-punk music and culture when I should be working on my admissions essay for the Master's program I want to get into. Granted, I'm learning something, but it's not the best use of my time at the moment.

So sure, one can take the stance that going online is better than watching television, but I disagree. Although I love the internet, I recognise it as having equal potential for education and for fettering your life away looking at LOLcats all day. It can be used for good or ill, like television, like gin, like fire, like anything, really. It isn't the medium, it is the operator/viewer/user who is responsible for the quality of time spent.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Further explorations in Web 2.0

In response to the Learn 2.1 lesson, Web 2.0 Continues, I went to the SEOmoz's 2008 Web 2.0 Awards site and puttered around a few websites to get a feel for them.

An honorable mention, I checked out CrazyMenu.com to see what Orlando businesses had their listings and menus up. Well, I guess the website has potential, if you have a dedicated user group who will plug in businesses and menus. But as of now, I prefer Urban Spoon. I gave Bikes, Beans & Bordeaux an "I like it" vote because the place is a great local sandwich shop and cafe, and the owners are super-nice. Clicking on a list for "cheap eats" brought up Udipi Cafe, a place I've been wanting to go to in Longwood for sometime now. I'm just hardly ever in Longwood.

As one of the ones frustrated with Last.fm's update earlier this year (gah, we went from a gorgeous website to something so poorly designed and ill-working... grumble, grumble), I was interested to see if Mog would be a suitable replacement. Sadly, many of the images didn't come up on Internet Explorer (Mozilla Firefox, anyone?), but a happy shard of light was the ability to listen to streamed songs in their entirety, or at least that was the case with one of my most favouritest bands, The Clientele. Have a listen to Rain by The Clientele and let me know what you think.

I don't know if Mog will replace Last.fm for me, as I'm still kind of iffy on the design of the website, but they get props for having The Clientele up for all to listen to.

What, how did Etsy get second place to Threadless? Shenanigans. Etsy is the super-jam, selling all kinds of stuff from all sorts of good people. According to my Etsy account, I've purchased 108 items since March 2006, and I'm currently waiting on a vintage 1950s/60s chiffon nightie-top in baby blue from Etsy seller madecute. This holiday season, I'll be turning to Etsy for unique gifts for the cool people in my life, and you should, too.

Oooh, BBC iPlayer! It's so sleek! So pretty! So... oh, bugger! I can't watch video unless I'm in the UK! Boo. At least I can listen to the radio, and BBC 6's Rock & Indie page looks dead cool. Since I'm on a work computer that doesn't have Real Player (double boo), I'll have to check out some of the audio when I'm at home, but it looks great.

As for the Adventure activity, I'll have to get to that one in a future posting.